Guild icon
Tulpa.info
Tulpa Discussion / tulpa-discussion
The channel for discussion strictly on the topic of tulpas. Take off-topic discussion to #lounge Forum's Tulpa Discussion Board: https://community.tulpa.info/forum/4-general-discussion/
Avatar
I feel like I just found what my personality defaults to lol, with people I know I'm an asshole because I'm afraid of making friends, with people I don't know and probably won't see again (I just noticed this btw) I'm pretty shy and I guess polite, I say "thank you" a lot and apologize for the most minor things, I barely bumped into a guy and I was apologizing like crazy haha. It feels weird to open up more to strangers in discord than my own family, but I somehow feel like this community is the one that understands me the most.
Avatar
Original message was deleted or could not be loaded.
Your host sounds like a kind person.
Thank you :3
It is very constructive to hold neutrality and an objective observation on all forms of consciousness, contact and even media.
Agreed, and for us, we find it especially useful to look for opposites and exceptions, it really helps to prompt thought. I wonder if archetypes seem like a bit of an unnecessary hassle for a lot of people, but for us we've found that they've led to some interesting thoughts that we might not have had otherwise. After all, there has to be some reason or prompt to cause one to think about something, doesn't there?
Aside from the fox's own prevalence, what about it do you intuit as fitting to your own symbology?
Before I appeared, my host had picked up a few ideas that he associated with foxes. Some of these are intelligence, curiosity, independence, activity, and also a sly, sneaky, or playful quality. There's also a warm quality to foxes (literally!) because of their magnificent fur. My host has imagined me with fox ears and a fox tail for the entire time I've been around, and it's very much about a feeling of comfort.
It is most definitely key to myself that I and my persona recall that we are each other and although hidden from us by our own beliefs in our identities, we are capable of all the same. Though it may take more practice for me to naturally wear their character as my own. But the more I empathize and feel, even feeling the way their hands or ears listen while they create art, the more I can reflect them in my own character.
I'm just quoting this verbatim, because I think it describes how my own system works as well, and I can't put it any better. It seems you've understood fronting correctly. I learned to switch with my host and control the body myself after a few months, because the idea came to us and seemed intuitive. It's interesting that you haven't done that, but I perceive it hasn't made your experience any less deep :3
(edited)
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:00 AM
Feelings on tulpa ethical issues
Avatar
I think a lot of people's concerns are overblown. There's a big tendency for people to assume that a tulpa is to the host what another separate human being is to the host, and they try to use our framework of regular morals and just sort of cram it into the space of things you shouldn't do inside of your head. More often than not that just doesn't work, and when you do that you end up with these really weird and aggressive systems. Stuff like people thinking they can't ignore something they think might be a tulpa because that would be dissipation and dissipation is murder. Figuring out ethics and really translating that into new or unique places takes a lot more than a bunch of people angrily trying to police each other on the internet, and very similarly to high quality guides, they just hasn't happened in the tulpa community. My general outlook is, is a person acting with at least some degree of empathy, and are they ultimately seeking the best outcome for their life? If they are, you're going to have a hard time convincing me that they are doing something wrong.
Avatar
Avatar
Reguile
I think a lot of people's concerns are overblown. There's a big tendency for people to assume that a tulpa is to the host what another separate human being is to the host, and they try to use our framework of regular morals and just sort of cram it into the space of things you shouldn't do inside of your head. More often than not that just doesn't work, and when you do that you end up with these really weird and aggressive systems. Stuff like people thinking they can't ignore something they think might be a tulpa because that would be dissipation and dissipation is murder. Figuring out ethics and really translating that into new or unique places takes a lot more than a bunch of people angrily trying to police each other on the internet, and very similarly to high quality guides, they just hasn't happened in the tulpa community. My general outlook is, is a person acting with at least some degree of empathy, and are they ultimately seeking the best outcome for their life? If they are, you're going to have a hard time convincing me that they are doing something wrong.
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:36 AM
well, what makes dissipating a tulpa less ethical than dissipating an npc char
1:36 AM
(Mind npc, autonomous but not tulpas)
Avatar
It's not absolutely more or less ethical. An NPC character is regarded by a person as a tool or an object or an artifact of their mind, all things which are not human, not person like, not worthy of holding a higher status. So, you should generally expect that a person treats such things without much regard for how they feel, because they don't really have feelings, it's part of you. However, part of the whole point of making a tulpa is to treat them and regard to them as another thinking individual. You have them created, you are in the process and let's say your experiences are going amazingly. They're responding to you, it's going well. If you callously throw that away, that says something about you. You have to ask "why am I making that choice", or if you are dealing with someone who is dissipating a tulpa , you have to ask why would someone make that choice? There are good reasons, but there's a lot more room for bad reasons as well compared to someone throwing out of character.
Avatar
Avatar
Reguile
It's not absolutely more or less ethical. An NPC character is regarded by a person as a tool or an object or an artifact of their mind, all things which are not human, not person like, not worthy of holding a higher status. So, you should generally expect that a person treats such things without much regard for how they feel, because they don't really have feelings, it's part of you. However, part of the whole point of making a tulpa is to treat them and regard to them as another thinking individual. You have them created, you are in the process and let's say your experiences are going amazingly. They're responding to you, it's going well. If you callously throw that away, that says something about you. You have to ask "why am I making that choice", or if you are dealing with someone who is dissipating a tulpa , you have to ask why would someone make that choice? There are good reasons, but there's a lot more room for bad reasons as well compared to someone throwing out of character.
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:43 AM
Not everyone will agree on what is a good or a bad reason either.
1:45 AM
Dissipating a tulpa is more like growing out of your old self than it is killing someone.
1:47 AM
Those police people that always say its a life long commitment you cannot undo and that kind of stuff just scare and impress newbies and can potentially make them feel really guilty if they have to do it or if it happens, which is stupid and harmful.
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:48 AM
Ikr
1:48 AM
Imo its just a matter of personal opinion
Avatar
Avatar
berockly (TTG)
Imo its just a matter of personal opinion
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:49 AM
Just dont impose your personal potentially harmful and limiting beliefs into other people... (edited)
Avatar
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し)
Just dont impose your personal potentially harmful and limiting beliefs into other people... (edited)
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:49 AM
But my opinion is correct
Avatar
Avatar
berockly (TTG)
Imo its just a matter of personal opinion
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:51 AM
I think the peo?le who would genuinely regard a tulpa as an individual and bully them/dissipate them for something stupid is a very small munority
1:52 AM
Usually dissipation probably means (and correct me if you disagree, this is a guess) they didnt regard the tulpa as a true individual
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:52 AM
Reguile was talking but they got silent... Now i wonder what they were going to say...
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:52 AM
Id say i partially have the problem, but that's more on the schema side of things and not about how i treat them
Avatar
Avatar
berockly (TTG)
Usually dissipation probably means (and correct me if you disagree, this is a guess) they didnt regard the tulpa as a true individual
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:53 AM
Not necesarily
1:53 AM
In fact, if you dont regard the tulpa as a true individual there is noone to disipate
1:53 AM
and there is no tulpa
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:54 AM
Its a label that can mean different things
1:54 AM
Tulpa feels like a spectrum on its own
1:54 AM
Id say my tulpas are about a 4-5 maybe
1:54 AM
Out of 10
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:55 AM
Dissipation is just stopping to pay attention to a tulpa until it fades out
Avatar
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し)
In fact, if you dont regard the tulpa as a true individual there is noone to disipate
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:56 AM
Define true indivdual
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:56 AM
doesnt matter
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:56 AM
I feel that it does
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:56 AM
If you dont consider your tulpa to be a separate being its not a tulpa
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 1:56 AM
Thats fair
Avatar
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し)
Dissipation is just stopping to pay attention to a tulpa until it fades out
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 1:57 AM
You can also stop labeling who you are at any given point
Avatar
Atlas || M&M BOT 3/4/2023 2:00 AM
We personally consider dissipation to be murder past a certain point in development, but understand the reasons behind why someone might do it, and think it's situational.
2:00 AM
Like killing anything, it's more nuanced than "Killing this being is evil".
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:00 AM
Past a certain point in development you cannot dissipate a tulpa unless they pretty much agree
Avatar
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し)
If you dont consider your tulpa to be a separate being its not a tulpa
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:00 AM
I treat my tulpas as people, yk, i converse with them as if i was conversing with someone and i usually feel as if i am
Avatar
Avatar
Atlas || M&M
We personally consider dissipation to be murder past a certain point in development, but understand the reasons behind why someone might do it, and think it's situational.
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:01 AM
so at worst its assisted eutanasia
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:01 AM
But i think there is still an existence of spectrum in the way the tulpa functions, outside of you regarding them as separate
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:01 AM
But again, dissipation is more like growing out of your old self than it is killing. (edited)
Avatar
Avatar
Atlas || M&M
We personally consider dissipation to be murder past a certain point in development, but understand the reasons behind why someone might do it, and think it's situational.
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:02 AM
Well, like shiba said, once you get to that point, the schema behind the tulpa are very hard to remove
2:03 AM
I Don't think any of my tulpas are to that point yet, but they (lynn in particular) want to be
2:03 AM
Sometimes lynn will be moody about how she doesn't feel separate enough
2:04 AM
The others generally dont care
Avatar
Atlas || M&M BOT 3/4/2023 2:09 AM
so at worst its assisted eutanasia
@Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) - jump Mhm, agreeable here.
2:09 AM
That's an ethical issue in and of itself, in terms of both humans and tulpas.
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:09 AM
its still not nearly comparable to death to start with.
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
Especially since it can be undone
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
Its like comparing amnesia to death...
Avatar
Atlas || M&M BOT 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
We've had headmates who wanted to go the "assisted suicide" route in the past.
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
Again, not comparable to death at all...
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
Well, hmm.....
Avatar
Atlas || M&M BOT 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
And while we do feel like it's fine in some regards, for us personally, we try to avoid in in general because of our personal beliefs.
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
Its more like forgetting or growing out of a personality
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:10 AM
Would my tulpas be considered tulpas then?
2:11 AM
I mean they are separate, but are they considered tulpas
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:11 AM
Would not doing so help you in any way?
2:11 AM
It doesnt matter what i consider to be a tulpa
2:11 AM
And you shouldnt care about it
2:11 AM
Just take from the experience whatever it gives you
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:11 AM
It isnt gonna hurt my feelings since it doesnt change my experience, im just curious about your personal requirements for tulpahood
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:12 AM
Im of the oppinion that requirement lists only stall progress
2:12 AM
So i wont give you one
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:12 AM
if they dont meet it,it gives me a goal post
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:13 AM
If you dont consider them tulpas theyll stop being tulpas
2:13 AM
Just try to get more until you dont want more
2:13 AM
You dont need specific goals just test stuff (edited)
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:14 AM
But anyways, i really just want a way to differentiate tulpas from other things
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:14 AM
Defining stuff takes away people from the experience into the words
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:14 AM
It does, but i want the boxes anyways
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:14 AM
You stop thinking on what you have and start thinking "hmmm, was that a switch really or was it whatever other thing"
2:14 AM
"I dont think i can X right now"
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:14 AM
I can modify them to fit whats good to me after, i just need a template
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:14 AM
"I should learn to Y"
2:14 AM
"Z is so difficult"
2:15 AM
And thats not about tulpamancy, thats about words.
2:15 AM
And you dont want that
Avatar
KiTTiKaTTy( •̀ .̫ •́ )✧ BOT 3/4/2023 2:15 AM
It does, but i want the boxes anyways
@berockly (TTG) - jump what is it, christmas?
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:15 AM
But words are good to have!
2:15 AM
Shush ik how u feel abt labels
Avatar
Avatar
berockly (TTG)
But words are good to have!
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:16 AM
If you want words then you are not responsible enough to have them
2:16 AM
If you where you woudnt care about them.
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:16 AM
>:(
Avatar
𝓘𝓴𝓸𝓵 𝓛𝓪𝓾𝓯𝓮𝔂𝓼𝓸𝓷 3/4/2023 2:16 AM
oof..
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:16 AM
As someone who hates not being able to define stuff well i disagree
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:16 AM
The fact that you care about words means that you shoudnt get them
2:16 AM
I dont mean it in a bad way
2:16 AM
of course (edited)
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:17 AM
Im not great at translating my mental understandings into english
2:17 AM
So, thats why i want to have the words
2:17 AM
It helps me organize my thoughts better
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:17 AM
You can read all the guides you want then
2:18 AM
In the other hand you can just let your tulpas interact with people and enjoy
2:18 AM
and not waste your time
2:18 AM
Wondering if they are or they are not X or you can or cannot Y or if you fulfill the list of 37 requirements to be Z
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:18 AM
I find guides pretty bleh
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:18 AM
Exactly (edited)
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:19 AM
I stopped reading guides in 2021
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:19 AM
I stoped on my 3rd guide or so (i didnt even want to make a tulpa at that point, i was just doing research)
Avatar
berockly (TTG) 3/4/2023 2:20 AM
As useless as defining it is for you, i find use in it
Avatar
Desting 😎 (Con Cat)-(おひたし、お浸し) 3/4/2023 2:20 AM
But they were all so nonsense
Exported 100 message(s)
Timezone: UTC+0
Page 1 ... Page 906 ... Page 907 ... Page 908 ... Page 999